CLAIM-953216reported
“A Bastia family reportedly obtained three color photographs of a disc-like object with upper structure.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · Bastia photographic series; uploaded PDF pp. 306-306
← ENCOUNTERS DIRECTORYHOW TO READ THIS → HOW TO READ THIS →CONTEXTUALIZES HOW TO READ THIS →SUPPORTS HOW TO READ THIS →SUPPORTS CONTEXTUALIZES HOW TO READ THIS →SUPPORTS
E-009614LANDMARK CASE · HIGH CORROBORATIONDATE PRECISION: exactRECORD COMPLETENESS: 100%
Bastia Family Three-Photograph UFO Series
1971-02-12Bastia, Corsica, France
A family in Bastia reportedly obtained three color photographs of a disc-like object with upper superstructure. Hall had limited camera and investigative data.
Claims are displayed with the source wording, locator, relationship and verification state. Competing claims remain separate rather than being averaged into a single answer.
SOURCE COMPARISON
Encounter · Hall Volume II Encounter Claim
SUPPORTS
SOURCE COMPARISON
Encounter · Hall Volume II Source Caveat
CLAIM-953217reported
“Hall had little witness-character, camera or analytical information for the case.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · Bastia provenance limitations; uploaded PDF pp. 306-306
SOURCE COMPARISON
Hall Volume II Photographic-Evidence Framework · Hall Volume II Source Framework
CLAIM-953200reported
“Hall retains the 1964 principle that a still photograph is only approximately as reliable as the person who took it and the documented circumstances surrounding it.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · Photographic evidence witness-reliability principle; uploaded PDF pp. 297-299 · PRIMARY SOURCE
SOURCE COMPARISON
Hall Volume II Photographic-Evidence Framework · Hall Volume II Evidence Claim
CLAIM-953201reported
“Hall evaluates six factors: witness character, strangeness, camera technical data, direct testimony/circumstances, completeness of analysis and peer review.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · Hall six-factor photographic rating methodology; uploaded PDF pp. 297-299 · PRIMARY SOURCE
CLAIM-953230disputed
“Hall discusses an anomalous October 1978 DMSP weather-satellite image obtained through an Elmendorf AFB weather center. Bruce Maccabee reportedly ruled out several image artifacts but could not fully exclude a satellite or space-debris object.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · October 1978 DMSP weather-satellite anomalous image; uploaded PDF pp. 312-313
Multiple claim rows are intentionally retained when sources disagree. ANOMALY does not silently reconcile competing values.
SOURCE COMPARISON
Hall Volume II Photographic-Evidence Framework · Hall Volume II Source Caveat
CLAIM-953202reported
“Hall stresses that a technically authentic image does not by itself establish the identity or extraordinary origin of the photographed object.”
The UFO Evidence, Volume II: A Thirty-Year Report
SRC-009500 · Image authenticity versus object identity caveat; uploaded PDF pp. 297-299 · PRIMARY SOURCE